I’m still so sad over it all. I’ve been waiting for evidence of this. Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email. Why not perform for a candidate you actually do believe in? Many others cancelled after outcry from fans. Deliveroo couriers boycott restaurant chain in York in row over waiting times. But that’s exactly why her situation was different. I’ve been hoping that they would really do something concrete. I haven’t listened to the several albums of theirs that I already owned since their decision. You compared yourself to Marian Anderson, who performed at a time when neither party could claim to be supporting Black Americans. And this song is such a tearful tribute, though I cry whenever I hear it. Neither is this solely a party political issue. This only works if people co-operate. Now, not so much. She knew that to perform at an inauguration at all would be a slap in the face to racists, regardless of their political affiliation. Nailed it . If you want to fight xenophobia, why not give a benefit concert for the ACLU? Trump’s apparent contempt for serious journalism deploys a brazen steamroller to circumvent verifiable facts. You specifically said you support immigrants and women. Just as Trump’s actual inauguration was sparsely attended, the pre-inauguration concert was also a somewhat desultory affair in terms of the line-up. It seems apt that the inauguration of the first reality TV show President was overshadowed by discussions of audience size. 29. It can take almost any form, but the one thing it never does is stand by passively when the beloved is harmed or threatened. Pleasantness is not a virtue at all. His first weekend, and that of incoming White House Press Secretary Sean Spicer, was spent peddling disprovable falsehoods about the size of the crowds. The Civil Rights movement is a case in point. Up to 130 restaurants will declare a boycott against the current coronavirus-related restrictions in force across the country, and will shut down their delivery service on Saturday, January 30, as a sign of protest, Shota Burjanadze, a representative of the Georgian Restaurateurs Association, told Tabula. Reinhard Tristan Eugen Heydrich (/ ˈ h aɪ d r ɪ k /; German: [ˈʁaɪnhaʁt ˈtʁɪstan ˈɔʏɡn̩ ˈhaɪdʁɪç] (); 7 March 1904 – 4 June 1942) was a high-ranking German SS and police official during the Nazi era and a main architect of the Holocaust.He was chief of the … This article first appeared on The Conversation (theconversation.com). Trump’s is the politics of the playground – he (it almost always is a he) with the biggest toys, the cronies and the loudest voice gets to call the game. Your presence did not challenge him in any way. There is a difference between outreach and validation. I mean, when I think Paul and saying it was ok to eat meat offered to idols, I’m thinking that he’d also say that it was ok to eat meat from a store that supported homosexuality (since, in my mind, idolatry is just as big a sin as homosexuality). Adam Behr, lecturer in popular and contemporary Music, Newcastle University. But modern American politics is plugged into celebrity culture in a substantive fashion, and Trump’s personal obsession with his own ratings and celebrity status means that he craves such endorsement – to the point of making it up where it doesn’t exist. That’s why I no longer listen to your music. Inaugural events take place before the business of a new government has got properly underway. Vocal opposition is a central plank of resistance to any political tendency, and musicians have already started to make their voices heard – the 1,000 Songs project will provide a protest song for every day of Trump’s presidency, and there was a raft of “anti-inaugural” concerts across the country. And musicians are in a position to refuse, literally, to play along, and check the normalisation of the current administration. I would still disagree with your choice to perform at the inauguration, but I would at least trust that your letter was honest; that you were flawed, but not disingenuous. Both Powell and Wood advised the crowd to boycott the upcoming senatorial run-off ... What'd you guys do, ... You may be able to find more information about this and similar content at piano.io You just played for a man who has raped women, incited others to violence and is under investigation for treason. A boycott would be an intentional decision to avoid some business in order to make a point. Before the inauguration, I was looking forward to one day attending one of their live concerts. Briefings have been left unread, key roles still unfilled, and Trump’s first weekend in office has been most obviously marked by ramping up hostility towards the media. At the time of the inauguration, many celebrities saw that Donald Trump was A. dangerous in an unprecedented way and B. prone to seeing their presence at his events as an affirmation of what he stood for. The only thing they understand is money, so VOTE with your wallet and avoid anything they do!! Instead, we will start to enjoy REAL MUSIC once again! 3 Guys Did 200 Pushups a Day for 30 Days and Revealed the ... How can we not boycott the 2022 Beijing Games? Change ), You are commenting using your Google account. Their open letter didn’t land well when they wrote it and it lands less well in the face of continued silence from them. I might not have chosen to perform, even with outreach, at that inauguration, but I could respect someone’s decision to accept and then use that platform. It was kinda far from his apartment but he didn’t mind the drive if it met maybe getting to talk to Patrick some more. Challenging the false assertions that emanate from his office will obviously be a key means of attempting to maintain a healthy polity. Change ), You are commenting using your Facebook account. Change ). You did nothing newsworthy. This is because part of me has been waiting to see you prove that this validation came from lack of understanding, rather than lack of a desire to affect change. It is something we earn with work, with love, and with willingness to challenge those who would say, “tolerate oppression of others, or I will make your lives unpleasant.” When we skip the unpleasantness of difficult love, in a rush to get to superficial niceness, only the bullies benefit. The Piano Guys don’t often include words with their music but this song does. I interpreted this as a subtle hint that you were were going to use the performance to engage in active outreach, rather like how the cast of Hamilton had respectfully engaged Mike Pence earlier that year. Here is a good start with THE PIANO GUYS playing real (as opposed to TRASH music). But of course, that wasn’t your plan at all. A boycott would be an intentional decision to avoid some business in order to make a point. Post was not sent - check your email addresses! Social media slammed the club for supporting a band that offended the sentiments of Dalits. But in your description of this show, you seemed to think that A. the people who showed up were your enemy and B. because your music was so good you had some kind of transformative global impact. Do you not understand the difference between a nation’s leaders and their people? It’s only that your beautiful music lost something, and I’m writing this to try to explain why, to myself as much as the world. Simply by singing, as a Black woman, she was engaging in outreach to both parties. The sound of silence, withholding even tacit endorsement, especially to a President who so clearly covets it, is another. It’s hard to do, and not always received well, but when it works the results can be incredible. I don’t have a point here, nor a desire to convince others to stand with me. It clearly rankled Trump that by any metric the Women’s March the following day achieved far greater numbers in Washington DC, even before you start counting all the other associated demonstrations across the US and internationally. Typically Christmas cookies don't cause much controversy, but that wasn't the case with a set of Santa cookies being sold at Target. And if you didn’t actually think that, then your letter was a lie. The Piano Man Jazz Club in Safdarjung Enclave in south Delhi found itself in a controversy after it scheduled a performance by a music band called 'Bhangijumping'. NeNe Leakes is asking her followers to stop watching 'The Real Housewives of Atlanta' months after accusing Andy Cohen and Wendy Williams of being racists. Bruce Springsteen, whose main contribution to the transition was a private concert for Barack Obama’s outgoing staff, lauded the Women’s March as the “New American Resistance”. I’m sad! I agree that music is powerful and can bind us, but you’re painfully naive if you literally thought an admittedly brilliant mashup of Vivaldi’s Winter with Frozen’s Let it Go could magically un-racist a white supremacist. I haven’t been able to listen to anything from them since they announced they would be playing. Then you went home with your check. You performed for a man who spent over a year actively insulting every type of a minority to a degree that even members of his own party would not ordinarily stoop to. I wondered how Annie Schmidt’s death would affect The Piano Guy’s music this year. Outreach is when you see a person doing something wrong, call them out, but don’t let their wrong behavior stop you from talking to them as fellow humans. Therefore, most of them refused to appear at the inauguration. You said a good deal about your positive message of love and you affirmed the rights of women and immigrants. Very very wonderful and what steps do you guys think you can take as the ... #OscarsSoWhite: Stars Boycott Awards Over All-White Nominees. Perhaps you would point out how many of your hit videos have featured singers who were immigrants, or mention how, as Mormons, your people have a history of religious oppression and you believe no one should be denied freedom of religion. Just as Ewan McGregor refused to appear on Good Morning Britain because of Piers Morgan’s comments on the women’s march, many singers and artists refused to play at Trump’s inauguration, Find your bookmarks in your Independent Premium section, under my profile. No. It might take subtle action, it might bide its time for the opportune moment, but it does not make nice to abusers in the interest of keeping things superficially friendly, then turn it’s back on the abused. Politically Incorrect ART CLASS - Katie Couric Gets SUED By the Good Guys -AND- Sign... Divorce; Pamona College -RACIST Against White-BOYCOTT That ... BALCKmail-=follow the money and power- … Change ), You are commenting using your Twitter account. ( Log Out / I have been teaching music for the past 9 years. You used that show to indicate that music changed hearts, and implied that, therefore, it was your duty to perform even for people you disagreed with. Reviewing Christian Media as an Ex-Christian, Thoughts and Stories of Lane William Maxfield, How I Name My Characters, Part Three: Using Names to Serve the Story, J. K. Rowling and the Complex Gender Narrative, Reviewing the Screwtape Letters as a Witch: Prayer is Hard to do Wrong, Follow Thoughts and Stories of Lane William Maxfield on WordPress.com, Reviewing VeggieTales as an Atheist: Jonah Part Two, Reviewing Veggie Tales as an Atheist; King George and the Ducky, Reviewing VeggieTales as an Atheist; Larry-Boy and the Fib From Outer Space, Rereading the Screwtape Letters as an Atheist; Part One, Reviewing Veggie Tales as an Atheist; Silly Songs with Larry. When I first read it, it actually made me feel better. So why not be political in a truly bipartisan, healing spirit? You compared your choice to Barack Obama’s dignified handling of the transition. There’s certainly a long tradition of musical participation in positive mobilisation in American politics. It’s too late to say you don’t want to be political; we all know performing for a politician’s act is at least a partially political act, and you knew that going into this situation. But this withdrawal of musical labour aligns with the broader movement evidenced in the historic scale of the demonstrations at the weekend. Why did the impulse to write this open letter not leave, even after five months? Traditionally, the inauguration events have been a bi-partisan celebration of the office of the President, rather than of the incoming President himself, with a long history of artists – like Ray Charles and Frank Sinatra – playing across party lines or, like Jessye Norman, for both Republicans and Democrats. Alas. These are not comparable decisions. Also, his reactions tend to highlight his temperamental flaws and make it difficult for the media to normalize him. It’s been almost a year since you wrote this. ( Log Out / Headliners like country artist Toby Keith, YouTube act The Piano Guys and America’s Got Talent runner-up Jackie Evancho were no match for the star power on … That is all. I found your blog because I periodically search the web for some evidence that they’ve taking some further action acknowledging their error. That headline acts this year include country stars and reality-show runners-up is telling. Worst of all, you compared the inaugural performance to one you gave in an unnamed country that you perceived as hostile to the USA. Headliners like country artist Toby Keith, YouTube act The Piano Guys and America’s Got Talent runner-up Jackie Evancho were no match for the star power on display when the likes of Beyonce and Aretha Franklin performed for Obama. Since the "Fight Song" had been a fixture of Clinton's campaign, the decision to play it at Trump's inauguration raised eyebrows. That’s why I don’t know that that is our mission. He only did what he was legally required to, and he did not let democracy’s need for a smooth, peaceful transition stop him from imposing sanctions on Russia, protecting scientific data on climate change and preventing the new administration from erasing all evidence of their Russian ties. But short of outright duress, there’s little that can be done to bring unwilling musicians to the stage and there has been a broad consensus that Trump’s platform is not one they wish to share. But why do I care? Donald Trump's inaugural welcome concert next week will feature country star Toby Keith, singer Jennifer Holliday and actor Jon Voight, organizers announced Friday. Another bone of contention was the light attendance at his own events compared to those for Barack Obama on ascending to the presidency. It is telling, though, that the contempt of Hollywood and the musical world irks him. But given the Trump team’s own apparent disregard for the traditional unifying role of the transition and inaugural events, it seems appropriate that a bi-partisan artistic celebration of the constitutional process has been withdrawn. Well, I’m really angry because, to quote the song, you give love a bad name.
Red Secret Technique Performance Of A Hundred Puppets, Planting Goumi Berry, League Of Legends Keeps Crashing 2020, Maple Chips For Cookies, 2002 Legend Of Blue Eyes White Dragon 1st Edition, How To Prevent Pilling, 2 Sweet Potato Calories,